Investing and allocating capital

How Can a Family Tell Whether a Company's Growth Depends on Too Much Debt?

Short answer. Compare the company's debt payments with cash it produces, then test whether it can keep operating if sales slow, collections are delayed, or borrowing becomes harder. Ask what the borrowed money funded and whether it produced lasting cash generation. Debt becomes a concern when repayment depends on optimistic growth or repeated refinancing.

A company may be growing while becoming less able to meet its obligations. Review whether operating cash can cover debt payments and ordinary business costs, then test that capacity under weaker conditions. Growth funded by borrowing can work, but the company needs a credible way to repay or refinance without relying on ideal results.

Trace the Debt and Its Purpose

Ask for a complete list of borrowing, including balances, interest costs, repayment dates, collateral, guarantees, and restrictions. Confirm whether any obligations sit in subsidiaries or related entities. Then ask management what the borrowed funds paid for. Debt used to build productive capacity or fund a defined project has a different purpose from borrowing used to cover recurring operating losses.

Compare the expected benefit of each borrowing decision with what has happened so far. Did the spending produce the revenue, operating capacity, or cash generation management projected? If the plan changed, ask why and what the change means for repayment. Avoid treating a higher revenue figure by itself as proof that borrowing is working.

Test Repayment Capacity

Compare cash generated from ordinary operations with required interest and principal payments. Examine whether the company also needs cash for inventory, receivables, maintenance, or other operating needs. A business can report earnings but still face a cash shortfall if customers pay late or it must spend heavily to support growth.

Ask management to model slower sales, lower margins, delayed collections, and higher costs. Consider whether the company could still meet payments and keep operating if those conditions persisted. Review upcoming maturities and the assumptions behind refinancing plans. If refinancing is essential, understand what lenders would need to see and what happens if financing is unavailable or more costly.

Look for signs that debt is limiting operating choices. The company may have little flexibility to respond to a setback if nearly all available cash is committed to lenders. Ask whether borrowing agreements restrict additional debt, distributions, asset sales, or other decisions. Review collateral and guarantees with your attorney, and talk with your CPA about tax treatment and reporting.

Judge Debt in the Full Investment Plan

Debt risk depends on the company's business model, cash flow pattern, and assets. Get help from professionals who understand the industry and can test management's projections. Ask for supporting records and reconcile them to financial statements. In a direct investment, also consider your position in the capital structure and the rights you would have if the company misses its plan.

Put the expected return beside the risk of loss and the demands on your family's time. The cash flow review helps establish the repayment picture, while a review of the operating business adds context. Consider how much exposure fits your portfolio model and record the reasoning through investment committee procedures. You can also map assumptions in the direct deal return calculator.

Debt is senior to equity, so in the unfortunate event of a bankruptcy or company failure, there are varying levels of debt seniority, but creditors are always repaid before equity stakeholders.

Richard C. Wilson, The Single Family Office

Sources: The Single Family Office. Informational only, not financial, legal or tax advice.